I bought 15 sample aftershaves for scent, about 9 beard balms, and a few oils. My ratings:
Beard balms last about a workday
Sharp dressed man - 9.5/10 - a classic everyday scent (bought big tub after sample scent)
Barbershop - 9/10 - classic scent
Rambling man - 8.5/10 - took a few applications to appreciate it but it smells nice
Mountain man - 7/10 - it smells nice after a few hours in the beard but may buy again at some point in future
Piancenza - 7/10 - it’s a hit or miss for me. The aftershave is better than the beard balm in the same scent - a bit citrusy (reminds me of capri in Italy)
Executive man - 10/10 - phenomenal scent - a tad sweet on the nose (bought big tub after sample)
Deep Blue Sea - 10/10 - probably tied with D-503 for my favorite scent - very close to Chanel de Bleu (about to buy big tub of this scent)
D-503 - 10/10 - I wear this one as a beard balm almost every day (bought big tub after sample)
Christmas Eve - 1/10 - in my humble opinion, this should be a discontinued scent. I tried it a few times as a aftershave splash and I threw it out.
Margaritas in the arctic - 7.5/10 (summer scent) - very candy-like
Arkadia - 2/10 (but got compliments) - earthy smell. Not a fan - will probably throw out
Haverford - 3.5/10 - very old man leathery
Mountain man - 7.5/10 - another nice beard balm scent for me - not that poignant/offensive to the nose when on mustache
Sandalpiper - 8.5/10 - not a typical sandalwood scent but nice nevertheless (prefer as post shave balm)
Unscented - 10/10- it’s actually unscented so does the job (use as beard oil)