Creamy , chewy smells. Pleasant pumpkin pie smell. Lathering is excellent with a balance of supponification and velvet viscosity.

I love the Sterling Shave soaps. Amazing soap at an amazing price.

My Wife likes it. She reports I smell like a spicy Apple Turnover at bakery.
Perfect for Fall days.

It smells exactly like pumpkin pie with a graham cracker crust. Sadly it doesn't taste like pumpkin pie with a graham cracker crust. Though it is a perfect fall shave soap. Makes me think of Thanksgiving.

The scent is amazing! Not to strong not to faint. Lathers up quickly. Coverage is awesome and does not fade. Amazing shave soap as always.

With my first sniff I knew that Stirling had nailed this one. Great job Stirling! Fantastic and on point scent and paired with the aftershave splash..it's a perfect combo

Just got my order in today from Stirling and wow! This one smells amazing.

I never like the actual pie. I can’t wait to try this soap out. The scent is beautiful and pleasant. It’s nice. Can’t wait to use it.

Omg this pumpkin spice soap is amazing I love this one i don't know if I'm just weird but i always find myself opening it up to take a big whiff , idk what it is about this one but I get amazing shaves it lathers like no other maybe the cinnamon in it Idk but something different about this one i get better cushion and protection more than the other ones or maybe I'm just over exaggerating maybe not but this one i use more than any other ones and the scent it gives off my God Rod !! Your a genius

This soap is exactly what you think when you think of fall. I get a lot of the nutmeg, cinnamon, and clove, with just enough of the pumpkin. It is a strong scent that lasts a while. Overall a great scent that I cannot recommend enough.

AWSOME ,great lather ,great slickness ,and I shave with straight razor

Just recieved my pumpkin spice soap and after shave !!!! And OH BOY !!! Does it smell ever so good. Fall is definitely in the air boys and girls. This stuff is legit, smells like pumpkin pie and ginger snaps in the background soooooooo good !! Way to go Sterling thanks for making my fall shaves complete 👍

This is not "basic". It smells like pumpkin pie and ginger snaps had a delicious baby! It's so nice to use. I ordered a sample and tried it - getting a full sized one and the post-shave lotion as well. This is a delightful gourmond scent that will be comforting and cheery - even though it's 90 degrees in Florida. It helped lend some "fall vibes" to the house. Nice post-shave feel and a fabulous lather! Treat yourself, guys and gals!

Love the scent of this shave soap, a good fall scent. To me it the a sweet ginger snap spicy scent to it. As with all Stirling shave soaps I've tried, it has a great slickness to it, a really good product. The scent stays with the soap the whole shave.

During the fall I'm so basic it's stupid. Basically any autumn-themed item I'm a sucker for. I can make up for it by at least buying a manly basic item. This definitely veers toward the sweeter side and is for sure in your face. I think it rounds out a bit as it blossoms, but if you're iffy on pumpkin spice to begin with, I would avoid. If you like having a pumpkin candle going in your home at all times like me, this is for you.

Not that it's a surprise, but the Pumpkin Spice shave soap I purchased in the fall 2018 still has the greatest scent profile even after one year and not as much use as last fall when I first purchased it. All of the Stirling shave soaps hold up well but I was very excited that this excellent classic is just like the first use. Great lather and scent wafts all throughout the shave den. The cushion is still top notch and slickness is always the best I've ever tried. Stirling products are cream of the crop.

This is one of my favorites. It smells wonderful. It performs great. A nice slickness and plenty of cushion. The razor just glides across my face. Unlike "Almost Heaven" this soap does not cause any irritation at all. It is one that I will be purchasing again.

The scent is warm and comforting and shaves like a smooth gem...so typical of Stirling shave soaps. I have only used the 2018 scent profile so cannot compare to prior years, but the scent is wonderful and reminds me of my grandmother's kitchen in the fall. I do not have skin allergies so I cannot comment on that, but I will say that the shave was exceptional and it's almost (good) torture to have this scent right by your nose and mouth! Started with the sample size, loved it and then purchased the shave jar so I have all of that goodness for when this is retired until next years creation!

You must buy if you love the warm scents of the fall.

Wiped a couple tears from my eyes while shaving with this soap. Memories of Grandmother's Pumpkin bread hot out of the oven comes to mind when shaving with this soap. Never had any face or neck burn with this soap either. Was a little concerned about that but if you are not sure buy a sample as Rod stated in the description of this soap. Has the high quality you come to expect from Rod and Amanda at Stirling Soap Co. - This is a keeper for sure! Get ya some!

I just ordered the pumpkin spice. It smells great and lathers up real good.its like a scented candle. Great customer service i can't wait to order more of thier soaps.for a good scent thick lather u can't go wrong with pumpkin spice or any other Sterling shave Soap. Barber shop is also great.

As with all of Stirling's soap's, the lather is phenomenal, the slickness, aceptional and the scent, if you like pumpkin spice, makes you want to take a bite. That being said, overall, you should be very satisfied with this soap.

I wasn't sure I was going to like it, but all of the shave soaps are great, produce excellent lather, so much so that face-lathering is easy.
The scent is mild, and is completely gone in 30-45 minutes, which is what I want: great scent while it's there, but doesn't mess up the scent of the after shave.

Absolutely delicious scent. I can sit at my desk and just keep the puck up to my nose for hours. Unfortunately, like the hot apple scent, leaves my face feeling pretty hot and red, though this dissipates quickly after washing off. Excellent product otherwise.

I always want to stick my face into an pumpkin cheese cake before. It like spreading desert on your face minus the whip cream. What a great smell and rich lather I have found my one and only THANK YOU stirling soap.

Only Stirling product I have ever had a problem with. In fact this is the only one I would not rate 5 stars.

Something in this soap turns my face bright red and hot to the touch. It's the cinnamon I presume. Granted there is a fair warning in the description. Scent is outstanding and same great performance. If you think there is a chance of skin irritation for you order the sample size.

I have yet to try every single puck from Sterling. However, that is because I am considered a ''stick to what works for me'' type of guy. I have tried a few of the shave pucks, can't beat it for the price and value. I recently purchased the pumpkin spice back in October and It's still a solid puck! they last so long. And I shave at the least every other day. They are easy to lather, the lather is massive, it's slick, and I love the value. And the scent of course is a real treat. I will continue supporting Sterling Soap! Slainte!

5 Stars all day every day....I've tried almost all of Rod and Mandy's recent seasonal releases, and this is the best! It's not cloyingly sweet like actual pumpkin pie, but the spices and the scent of a kitchen that has just baked a pumpkin pie, if that makes any sense. Great performance, not a surprise at all since that is a hallmark for Sterling, great post shave feel! The lather will just explode out of the puck if you even threaten it with a brush and water!

One of my favorites scents right now from Stirling, pumpkin spice is well... pumpkin spice. Lathering is superb as any other Stirling soap and oh my the scent, it smells so wonderful and delicious that sometimes it's like I'm putting a pumpkin pie on my face. Can definitely smell the cinnamon and has a nice feeling on the face. Can highly recommend this soap, especially for the cold Fall/Winters shaves.

I was lent this soap by my brother, and shaved with it a few days ago. I think it goes without saying that the thick lather, and slickness of Stirling Soaps is never an issue I worry about. I enjoyed the scent, it might have been a touch on the "sweet" side. I had no kind of cinnamon reaction to this soap like others (unlike my experience with Stirling Hot Apple Cider). I tend to prefer citrus and fruit scents, and I avoid "musk" scents like the plague, but this one wasn't bad. If you enjoy a sweeter scented soap, and pumpkin scents you would enjoy this soap.

Great fall scent and lather. Customer service is wonderful.

An amazing soap... a great smell and a great lather....
But my face turned red and burned from the cinnamon....way too strong.... I'm sad now.
If there's a way to dilute/cut it please let me know...